Uncovering secrets across Red Dead Redemption 2 often takes Arthur Morgan to the far edges of the map, far away from standard town settlements. Among the game's most intriguing side activities is tracking down the Torn Treasure Map pieces, which eventually lead to Otis Miller's unique revolver. Finding the very first fragment requires venturing deep into the northern woods of West Elizabeth to locate a Hermit living in isolation.
Journeying to Manito Glade
The first piece of the Torn Treasure Map is hidden inside a secluded cabin known as Manito Glade, located north of Annesburg in New Hanover. As you approach this remote wilderness location, you should remain vigilant as the local resident is hostile to outsiders. Approaching the front porch will trigger a sudden confrontation with a hermit armed with a powerful shotgun.
Defeating the Hermit is necessary to clear the cabin for safe exploration and looting. Once the area is secure, step inside the small timber cabin to locate your primary target. Searching the small bedside drawer reveals the first half of the torn map alongside rare ammunition and collectible items.
Understanding the Clues on the Map Fragment
Examining the first map piece in your inventory reveals a crude drawing depicting a distinct geographic landscape. The illustration highlights a prominent rock formation near a body of water, hinting at a location further west. Players following daily gaming news often emphasize the importance of studying these sketch details early to save time during exploration.
While this single piece cannot point directly to the buried treasure on its own, it provides the essential half needed to complete the set. You will need to keep this document safe in your satchel while tracking down the second half located on the opposite side of the map near Little Creek River.
Locating the Complementary Map Half
To assemble the full map, Arthur must travel west toward the border of West Elizabeth to find the Hermit Woman's cabin. This second hermit lives in a secluded hut surrounded by aggressive dogs, requiring careful positioning during your approach. Inside her home, another drawer contains the second torn map fragment needed to finish the puzzle.
Combining both pieces merges the drawings into a single legible map with clear directions. This completed guide points players toward Rattlesnake Hollow in New Austin, where the final reward resides inside a hidden cliffside cave. Taking the time to collect both pieces ensures access to one of the rarest weapon collectibles in the game.
Claiming Otis Miller's Revolver
With the completed Torn Treasure Map in hand, head south into New Austin toward the rocky ridges near Cholla Springs. Inside the small cave entrance described on the map, players will discover a decorative chest sitting in the dark. Opening this chest rewards you with Otis Miller's Revolver alongside a stack of erotic photographs.
This unique firearm features custom golden engravings and distinct stats that set it apart from standard sidearms. Successfully completing this hunt adds a valuable historical piece to Arthur's arsenal and completes one of the game's most subtle open-world mysteries.